Are Suicidal Thoughts Your True Self? Understanding Suicidal Thoughts
- Dr. Scott Eilers, PsyD, LP
- May 1
- 3 min read
When suicidal urges show up, the question that often follows them is brutal in its simplicity. Which version of me is the real one? The one who wants to keep going, or the one who wants out?
I want to tell you what I've learned after years of sitting with this question myself and walking through it with people who live inside it. Your suicidal thinking is not a character reveal. It does not pull back the curtain on who you really are underneath everything else. Let me explain why.
Most Suicidal Urges Are a Desire to Escape, Not to Die
Suicidal ideation usually represents a desire to escape something painful, not a literal preference for death. When I'm stuck in traffic and my brain pictures my truck turning into a monster truck so I can drive over every car blocking me, I don't actually want to commit mass vehicular murder. I just don't want to be stuck in traffic. My brain offered a dramatic escape from an aversive moment.
The same thing happens with suicidal thinking. Your brain wants the painful thing to end, and death is the most extreme exit it can offer. If a different option felt genuinely available, most people would take it in a heartbeat. They just can't always see one from where they're standing.
Intrusive Thoughts and Impulsive Thoughts Look the Same
Some of what you're calling suicidal thinking might not even be a desire at all. An intrusive thought is your brain warning you about something you do not want to happen. An impulsive thought carries actual desire behind it. They can look identical from the outside.
If the thought stresses you out or freaks you out, that's usually your brain saying "please don't let this happen." That's the opposite of a true self showing up.
Why Suicidal Thinking Becomes a Bad Habit
For a lot of people, suicidal thoughts started as a coping mechanism. Knowing where the door is made the party tolerable. The problem is that mental pathways stick around. You can lean on that escape route for so long that it becomes automatic, popping up in response to mild stressors that do not deserve it. I'll mess up a piece of paperwork I can fix in thirty seconds, and my brain will say "you should just die." That's not a genuine desire. That's a habitual trace of a coping mechanism I once relied on heavily.
If I lived in Germany long enough that I started thinking in German, I still wouldn't be German. The way your brain talks to you doesn't change who you are underneath it.
Pay Attention to the Biological Patterns
This part matters more than people realize. Notice whether your suicidal urges spike when you're exhausted, undernourished, or generally running on empty. If they do, that directly contradicts the idea these urges represent your true self. They represent your brain operating without the resources it needs to function.
That observation also points to something you can actually do. Sleep hygiene and consistent nutrition sound boring, and they're often the most effective intervention I've watched people make in their own lives.
I walk through how to think about these urges and what to do with them in the video below.
The Version of You That's Worth Getting Back To
The way your brain speaks to you in your hardest moments is not a more honest version of you. It's a symptom, a habit, a distortion produced by a system running low. The clearer-thinking version of you, the one with sleep and food and some breathing room, is closer to the real thing. That version is still in there, and it's absolutely worth getting back to.
(If this post hit home, you’ll probably connect with my new book, The Light Between the Leaves. It’s a practical guide for the days when “try harder” stops working.
-Scott
Want practical tools for navigating life with depression and anxiety, delivered right to you every week?
Resources.
If your brain has never felt like it’s on your side, I wrote this for you.
Get my book, The Light Between the Leaves
This book is for those suffering with depression and feeling unseen and helpless,
I see you because I was you.
Get my book, For When Everything is Burning.
FAQ
Q: Can anxiety routines be a sign of depression?Yes. Many people with high-functioning depression use anxiety routines as coping strategies. These routines often mask deeper struggles but also keep people stuck.
Q: What’s the difference between healthy preparation and an anxiety routine?Preparation helps you engage with life. Anxiety routines prevent you from living it. The difference is whether the habit expands or shrinks your world.
Q: What if I’ve tried therapy and it hasn’t helped?You’re not broken. Traditional therapy often overlooks people who need practical, science-based strategies. That’s why I share tools that most mental health providers aren’t teaching.
Really appreciate you covering this topic so clearly and thoughtfully. The way you explain it makes something heavy feel much more understandable. Thank you for putting this out there.